Last Updated on October 24, 2023 by Neil Sharma
Short-lived affordability gains in Canada’s housing market receded in the third quarter of the year, owing to voracious demand for detached housing and nascent signs of income precarity.
A report from Economics noted that market activity during Q2 was quelled by the coronavirus, unintentionally boosting affordability. However, those gains were all but lost in the June quarter.
“All markets we track saw an overall deterioration in ownership affordability,” stated the report from RBC Economics’ Robert Hogue. “Perhaps more noteworthy, the pandemic created new market dynamics impacting affordability trends differently across categories. Chief among them are soaring demand for larger living space and reduced attachment to live in, or near, core urban areas. Single-detached and other low-rise homes have become highly coveted and pricier as a result. And the ability to work from home has helped spread the heat—and affordability erosion—to all sorts of markets.”
That scorching demand for ground-related housing erased the affordability gains made in major Canadian cities’ condo submarkets. For example, although RBC’s condo apartment affordability measure decreased (indicating greater affordability) in Toronto because of a supply glut, its single-detached affordability measure increased far more.
Moreover, Toronto-based, president of CanWise Financial and co-founder of Ratehub.ca, is dubious that affordability ever returned to the housing market, even with surplus condominium supply, because historically low interest rates surged demand.
“Affordability issues have not gone anywhere—they never left—and I think in the mortgage industry, we’re looking for slow and stable growth,” he said. “We don’t want things to get too out of hand like they were in 2017 when the housing market was out of control. Absolutely, [low rates] will add to existing affordability issues.”
The RBC Economics report nevertheless contends that Canadians temporarily enjoyed elevated affordability during the second quarter, thanks to generous government financial aid in the form of the Canada Emergency Response Benefit.
“A partial retracement in government transfers caused household disposable income to fall 3.1% in the third quarter. With the imminent start of mass vaccination brightening the economic outlook in 2021, we expect further dialling down of transfers in the period ahead.”
Sustained property appreciation will also eat away at those Q2 affordability gains through 2021, in some regions more than others, but low mortgage rates can offset some of that.
“Buyers in Canada’s least affordable markets—Vancouver, Toronto and Victoria—are most vulnerable to any erosion in affordability given how stretched they already are, especially when shopping for a single-detached home,” said the report. “Local buyers in many smaller markets may also be challenged by rapid price increases. Strong demand is putting intense pressure on their housing stock.”
However, the report proffers a clue about where to find respite from the bidding wars and rapidly escalating prices that have in Canada for the last few years. Save for Ottawa, virtually all Canadian markets were more affordable last quarter than in Q3-2019, and rising affordability woes are predominantly a consequence of robust demand for single-family detached houses.
“Condo apartments are a generally more achievable option for buyers,” said the report.
Neil Sharma is the Editor-In-Chief of Canadian Real Estate Wealth and Real Estate Professional. As a journalist, he has covered Canada’s housing market for the Toronto Star, Toronto Sun, National Post, and other publications, specializing in everything from market trends to mortgage and investment advice. He can be reached at neil@crewmedia.ca.
